Lotus ScanManaBox vs Dragon Shield
Which MTG card scanner is better for you? A detailed comparison of features, accuracy, pricing, and more.
ManaBox and Dragon Shield are both available on iOS and Android with free tiers that let you try before committing to a subscription. ManaBox positions itself as a full-featured companion app with deck building and scanning, while Dragon Shield focuses on scanning with its unique AR translation feature for foreign-language cards. Both have significant free tier limitations that push users toward premium. Let us see which delivers more for your money.
Quick Overview
Detailed Comparison
| Feature | ManaBox | Dragon Shield |
|---|---|---|
| Scanning Accuracy | 3/5 Decent accuracy on a clean white background but struggles with foils and reflective surfaces. Works consistently enough for standard card scanning in controlled conditions. | 2/5 Initial recognition is quick, but frequently picks the wrong version of reprinted cards. This variant misidentification is a persistent issue that undermines collection accuracy. |
| Scanning Speed | 4/5 Quick Mode accelerates scanning when conditions are right. The white background setup adds time, but actual recognition happens at a reasonable pace. | 4/5 Fast initial recognition speed. The real speed cost comes from needing to manually correct variant selections on reprinted cards, which interrupts the scanning flow. |
| Price Tracking | 4/5 Four marketplace sources provide a comprehensive pricing picture. Good for comparing prices across different platforms before buying or selling. | 4/5 Daily prices from four marketplaces with 30-day history charts. Pricing is solid, though wrong variant selection can display incorrect values for reprinted cards. |
| Collection Management | 4/5 Binder and list organization works well across platforms. The 5-deck free limit is restrictive but the overall system is well-designed. | 3/5 Limited to 100 cards on the free tier, which is extremely restrictive. Cannot export to several popular platforms, limiting interoperability. |
| Value for Money | 3/5 The 5-deck free limit pushes you toward premium quickly. Paying helps, but the scanning issues with foils remain even after subscribing. | 3/5 The 100-card free limit is one of the most restrictive in the category. The AR translation feature is unique but niche, and variant accuracy issues diminish overall value. |
Our Verdict
Neither app is perfect, but ManaBox edges ahead with more generous free tier limits and better overall collection management. Dragon Shield's AR translation is a genuinely unique feature for players who deal with foreign-language cards, but its chronic variant misidentification problem is a significant drawback. If you need basic cross-platform scanning and deck building, ManaBox is the safer choice. Consider Dragon Shield only if AR translation is essential to your workflow.
Consider Lotus Scan
Looking for an MTG scanner that combines fast AI-powered recognition, real-time price tracking, and collection management? Lotus Scan for iPhone delivers all three without requiring a white background or subscription.