How to Know How Much a Game Store Will Pay for Your MTG Cards

A step-by-step guide to help you know how much a game store will pay for your mtg cards quickly and accurately.

Know what each card sells for

Scan your cards, see current prices and export a list to sell. Free on iPhone.

Download on the App Store
6 stepsAbout 12 minutesWorks with Lotus Scan (iPhone)

A local game store has to resell what it buys, so it will pay less than market price. How much less varies by store, by card and by whether you take cash or store credit. The ranges below come from players\u2019 own reports on Reddit and public pages, not from an official source, so treat them as a guide. This guide shows how to price your cards first, so you can tell whether an offer is fair.

Step-by-Step Guide

1

Price your cards before you ask

Scan your cards or look up each exact printing and note the current price. Without your own numbers you cannot tell whether an offer is fair. Our price checker guide explains which price to trust.

2

Separate the valuable cards from bulk

Pull out rares, mythics, foils and older cards. Stores often pay a flat rate per thousand for plain commons and uncommons, so selling the valuable cards by themselves usually earns more.

Tip: Check the pile before you sell it. A valuable card sold as bulk costs more than any fee.

3

Call or message stores first

Ask whether the store is buying, what it pays for singles and bulk, and whether you need an appointment. Not every store buys collections.

4

Ask for cash and store credit offers

Many stores pay more in store credit than in cash. Credit is only worth it if you will spend it there.

5

Compare the offer with market price

Divide the offer by your total market value. Players on Reddit report cash offers anywhere from about 30% to about 60% of market value, depending on the store, and stores often pay more for in-demand cards.

6

Consider other options for valuable cards

A buylist or a marketplace listing often pays more for expensive singles, at the cost of time and fees. Our guide to where to sell MTG cards compares the fees.

Typical Ways to Sell and What They Pay

These are general patterns reported by players and public sources. Offers vary by store and card.

OptionTypical payoutSpeedBest for
Local game store, cashA share of market value, often about 30% to 60% as players reportSame dayA quick sale of a large collection
Local game store, store creditOften higher than the cash offerSame dayPlayers who will spend it in the store
Buylist (for example Card Kingdom)A percentage of its buy price, with a bonus for store creditDaysA large stack of cards in one go
Marketplace listingClose to market price, minus feesSlowValuable singles
Bulk to a buyerRoughly $2 to $5 per 1,000 commons and uncommonsDaysThe cheap cards that remain

Compare where to sell

TCGplayer, Card Kingdom, Cardmarket, eBay and local stores on fees and speed.

Where to sell MTG cards →

Price your cards first

Which price source to trust and how condition and foil change the number.

MTG price checker guide →

Make It Easier with Lotus Scan

Lotus Scan for iPhone simplifies this entire process with AI-powered card recognition, real-time price tracking, and intuitive collection management. Just point your camera and scan.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much will a game store pay for my MTG cards?
It varies. Players report cash offers from about 30% to about 60% of market value, and sometimes more in store credit. These are anecdotal ranges, so ask several stores and compare the offer with your own prices.
Do game stores pay more in store credit?
Many do. A store credit offer is often higher than the cash offer, but it only helps if you will spend it in that store.
How much is MTG bulk worth?
Not much per card. Public sources put plain commons and uncommons at roughly $2 to $5 per 1,000, so the money is in the cards you pull out first.
Should I sell my collection to a store or online?
A store is faster and avoids shipping, but pays less. Online you usually get more per card but pay fees and ship each order. For valuable cards, compare both.
How do I know if a store offer is fair?
Add up the market price of your cards, divide the offer by that total, and compare the percentage with what other stores offer. A scan that gives the exact printing and price of each card makes this easy.
What if the store does not buy collections?
Ask whether it takes trade-ins, check other stores nearby, or look at a buylist or marketplace. Our guide to where to sell MTG cards lists the options.

Pro Tips

  • Do not accept the first offer for a large collection. Ask at least two stores.
  • Bring a printed or digital list with the printing and price of each card.
  • Keep expensive cards separate and ask for a separate offer on them.
  • Public sources put bulk at about $2 to $5 per 1,000 commons and uncommons, but check current rates.
  • If a store gives a very low number, ask how it priced the cards.
Ready to scan your MTG collection?
Download Lotus Scan free on the App Store.
Lotus ScanLotus Scan
We Like ToolsApp Hub ListTool SignalApp NetworkerThe Mega Tools