Archidekt vs Moxfield: Which Is Better for Your MTG Collection?
Two of the most popular Magic deck builders, compared on what matters when you also want to track the cards you own.
Archidekt and Moxfield are the two deck builders most Magic players end up comparing. Both are free to start, both run in the browser, and both will happily take a list of the cards you own. They differ in how much your collection matters while you build, and neither one scans a physical card for you.
This comparison looks at them from the point of view of someone who wants to track a collection, not only build a single deck.
The short answer
Pick Archidekt if you want your collection to take part in deck building, with owned cards marked and searchable. Pick Moxfield if you mainly want a fast, friendly deck builder and a place to share lists. Neither has a built-in card scanner, so for either one the practical way to track a physical collection is to scan it with an app, export a CSV, and import it.
Archidekt vs Moxfield at a Glance
Focused on what matters when you also want to track the cards you own. We checked each site and public community comparisons in October 2026, and both tools change often, so confirm current details on their sites.
| Feature | Archidekt | Moxfield | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best known for | Visual deck builder with strong card categories | Fast, friendly deck builder | Depends on taste |
| Built-in card scanner | No | No | Tie |
| Cost | Free; Patreon supporters get an ad-free experience | Free, with optional paid plans | Tie |
| Price sources | TCGplayer, Card Kingdom, Cardmarket and Cardhoarder | Shows prices on cards and decks | Archidekt, for clarity on sources |
| Collection import | Upload or import a list into your collection | Imports plain-text lists and CSV | Tie |
| Owned cards while deck building | Marks cards you own and can filter by your collection | Lighter, with basic flagging of cards you still need | Archidekt |
| Paper, MTGO and Arena | Tracked separately inside one account | Focused on deck lists | Archidekt |
| Deck export | Actions, then Export, then CSV | Export, then DeckBox CSV | Tie |
| Platform | Web | Web | Tie |
Where Archidekt wins
- Marks the cards you own while you build, and filters by your collection
- Keeps paper, MTGO and Arena collections separate in one account
- Documents its price sources: TCGplayer, Card Kingdom, Cardmarket and Cardhoarder
- Strong card categories and customization for how a deck is laid out
Where Moxfield wins
- Widely used, so decks are easy to share and find
- Community comparisons describe it as quicker for putting a deck together
- Accepts plain-text lists as well as CSV imports
- Free, with optional paid plans if you want extras
Which One Should You Pick?
Match the tool to what you actually do with your cards.
| If you want to | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Build decks from cards you already own | Archidekt | Owned-card marking and collection filters are its strongest point |
| Assemble and share decks as quickly as possible | Moxfield | Community comparisons describe it as easier for putting a deck together |
| Keep paper, MTGO and Arena collections apart | Archidekt | Collections are tracked separately inside one account |
| See where your cards are heading in value | A dedicated tracker | EchoMTG or a scanner app with price history do this better than either deck builder |
| Skip typing a collection in by hand | A scanner app plus either one | Scan, export a CSV, then import it |
Getting Your Collection Into Either One
Neither site reads a card with a camera, so the fastest route is the same for both.
Scan your cards with a scanner app
Use an app that records the exact printing and foil status, such as Lotus Scan on iPhone, ManaBox or Delver Lens. Check each match as you go.
Export a CSV
Export the whole collection, or one deck at a time if you are building from specific lists. The file also works as a backup.
Import into Archidekt or Moxfield
Upload the file, then check a small batch of 20 to 30 cards first to confirm the printings and quantities came through before importing the rest.
Tip: Include the set code and collector number in the export so the right printing is matched.
Step-by-step: Moxfield
The exact format that works, with no reformatting.
Import scanned cards to Moxfield →Step-by-step: Archidekt
Scan, export and import a collection into Archidekt.
Import scanned cards to Archidekt →Want more than these two?
Ten collection trackers compared on scanning, price history, cost and platform.
Compare the best MTG collection trackers →Frequently Asked Questions
Is Archidekt or Moxfield better for tracking a collection?
Does Archidekt or Moxfield have a card scanner?
Is Archidekt free?
Is Moxfield free?
Can I use both Archidekt and Moxfield?
Which is better for Commander?
Scan your collection first
Lotus Scan identifies the exact printing, keeps price history and exports a CSV that drops into Archidekt or Moxfield.
